Italian Neighbours by Tim Parks
Thursday, August 31st, 2006
Read this one back in May, but I want to shuffle it off to the second-hand bookshop, so I thought I’d do a small review just so I remember that I read it.
(Gee, I hope the author doesn’t Google himself and read that! I still feel uncomfortable writing things about living authors (the dead are fair game!), but I do try to be polite unless it’s a real stinker and they seriously have it coming.)
Anyhow, I’m sorry, Mr. Parks, but I didn’t care for it.
Sometimes, being a downer is mistaken for realism or honesty. But sometimes, a person is just standing there staring at the dog poo in the gutter. Life is too short for hanging out with people like this — in life or literature. Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not espousing sacharine, feel good rubbish. All I’m saying is that if your going to drag me through bleakness, it better be worth the ride. (see Dostoevsky)
I’ll grant that he does a good job of describing the place — but what a place! Who packs up their kit and moves to a run down suburb in a dumpy town, down wind from some chemical plants? Someone who likes to be depressed, that’s who. The whole thing just reeks of bleakness. Now, I have no problem with reality — I too loathe Peter Mayle — but this is swinging a bit too wildly to the opposite end of the spectrum. And to what purpose?
The author condescends, quirk hunts, has a patronizing attitude and is not very interesting. And I’m definitely not asking him to pet sit for me. (There’s a bizarrely long, drawn-out toying with the idea of poisoning the neighbour’s dog that I could have happily lived without.)
I found this book depressing and not very interesting, there weren’t (m)any insights and the company wasn’t engaging. Won’t read another by this author. Especially when there are so many other wonderful books about Italy. (i.e. Goethe’s Travels in Italy, H.V. Morton, Axel Munthe, etc…)
No tag for this post.

Here’s another one to skip! It will put you off the man and the island.